The Detroit Tigers began the offseason facing an unavoidable issue surrounding their superstar ace, fresh off his second consecutive American League Cy Young Award.
Even before it became official that Tarik Skubal was the first AL pitcher in more than 20 years to win the award in back-to-back seasons, speculation about his future was already swirling. With only one year of team control remaining before free agency and extension negotiations completely stalled, the tension was inevitable. That final season comes via arbitration, and when the two sides failed to agree on a salary for 2026, both submitted their figures.
Skubal filed at $32 million, while the Tigers countered with $19 million — creating the largest arbitration gap in MLB history. Unless an unexpected agreement is reached, the dispute is headed for a hearing in the coming weeks. Despite the escalating situation, Skubal appeared unfazed, posting a single-word caption — “Business” — on Instagram.
Skubal has consistently expressed his affection for Detroit and his desire to remain with the only major league organization he has ever known. At the same time, he has been clear that baseball is a business and that he would not accept a significant hometown discount. That message seemed reinforced by his post, which may have been directed not only at fans hoping he stays, but also at ownership amid negotiations many view as dismissive.
The Tigers have yet to present an extension offer that approaches Skubal’s market value, and their arbitration stance has only intensified frustration. A hearing in which the organization must argue that the game’s most dominant pitcher is worth far less than he claims risks causing lasting damage to the relationship.
Detroit typically avoids negotiating once the arbitration deadline passes, making it likely that a panel will decide whether Skubal earns $32 million or $19 million next season. If resentment continues to build, trade discussions could resurface before spring training. Ironically, a lower salary would only make Skubal even more attractive on the market.
More likely, Skubal will prevail in arbitration, putting pressure back on the Tigers to define the framework for a potential record-setting contract next offseason. Still, as has seemed increasingly likely for months, there is a growing sense that Skubal may be pitching in a different uniform a year from now. And if that becomes reality, responsibility will rest squarely with the Tigers’ front office and ownership.
Leave a Reply