With the Chicago Bears expected to choose USC quarterback Caleb Williams as the first overall pick in the upcoming 2024 NFL Draft, the real excitement begins with the Washington Commanders and their second overall pick.

After trading Sam Howell earlier in the offseason, Washington is in need of a quarterback and will likely use their first-round pick to address this position. However, the new Commanders General Manager, Adam Peters, faces a challenging decision regarding whether LSU’s Jayden Daniels or North Carolina’s Drake Maye is the better choice to potentially shape the franchise’s future.

Both Daniels and Maye possess exceptional talent, but their skill sets differ significantly, making it a tough decision for Peters. Each player is deserving of being selected with the second overall pick. Let’s carefully evaluate the strengths and abilities of both prospects and provide a recommendation for the Commanders.

According to Mel Kiper Jr. of ESPN, Jayden Daniels possesses exceptional talent as a dual-threat playmaker. He showcases the ability to elude and outmaneuver defenders while also displaying strength in running through contact. However, it is his improvement as a passer that has elevated his draft stock, positioning him as a potential first-round selection. Kiper acknowledges that Daniels benefited from having talented wide receivers like Malik Nabers and Brian Thomas Jr., but credits Daniels’ impressive skill set for directing the offense effectively.

Daniel Jeremiah of NFL Media describes Daniels as a tall and lean quarterback who demonstrates remarkable accuracy, decision-making, and speed. He exhibits poise and comfort in the pocket, throwing with anticipation, touch, and precision. Daniels also displays the capability to manipulate safeties with his eyes, creating opportunities for separation downfield. When faced with pressure, he reacts swiftly by utilizing his explosive mobility to escape the pocket. Overall, Daniels showcased significant development in 2023, showcasing both a high floor and a promising ceiling as a quarterback prospect.

OUR EVALUATION: Daniels displayed glimpses of immense potential during his initial three years at Arizona State before truly shining after transferring to LSU in 2022. Although his first season with the Tigers was respectable, it was in 2023 that Daniels truly stood out, leading the nation in total offensive yards with 4,946, throwing for 40 touchdowns and rushing for 10, ultimately earning him the prestigious Heisman Trophy.

At just 23 years old, Daniels presents a compelling case for being considered the premier deep-ball thrower among this year’s draft prospects. However, it is his dynamic rushing ability that truly sets him apart from other top quarterback candidates. Last season, Daniels amassed an impressive 1,134 rushing yards, the highest among all college football quarterbacks, with an average of 8.4 yards per carry, leading the entire FBS in this category.

FINAL DECISION: Choose Drake Maye

While Caleb Daniels may have a more impressive rookie season in terms of statistics, the better long-term investment for the Washington Commanders is Drake Maye. Despite Maye’s regression last season, losing his top receiver and adjusting to a new offensive coordinator likely contributed to his decline. However, even in a down year, Maye was more productive than Daniels was at the same age.

Maye’s skills are better suited to the NFL’s style of play, and he possesses a more durable frame. Considering these factors, Maye should be the clear choice for the Commanders.