The Detroit Tigers have moved beyond rebuilding. With Tarik Skubal capturing consecutive Cy Young Awards and heading into the final season of his contract, the signal from the organization should be unmistakable: the time to contend is now. Windows like this close quickly, and Detroit can’t afford to hesitate. If the Tigers truly want to maximize Skubal’s prime, bringing in Justin Verlander or Max Scherzer isn’t a luxury — it’s a necessity.
Skubal has fulfilled every expectation of a franchise ace. Over the past two years, he has established himself as the American League’s most dominant starter, combining elite strikeout ability with durability, command, and poise in high-leverage moments. Winning two Cy Youngs back-to-back cements his place among the game’s elite and raises the stakes for the front office to build properly around him.
With Skubal approaching free agency, patience is not an option. Seasons like this often define franchises — and wasting one can echo for decades. Detroit must act now or risk turning a historic run into a painful “what could have been.”
Detroit’s 2025 rotation showed promise but lacked certainty. Reese Olson continued to prove himself as a dependable starter behind Skubal. Casey Mize flashed the talent that once made him the top overall pick, while Matt Manning offered upside without consistent results.
What’s missing is a proven postseason presence — a veteran who has navigated pressure-filled pennant races and October starts. That stabilizing force could come in the form of Verlander or Scherzer.
Even late in his career, Justin Verlander remains a master technician. He no longer relies solely on overpowering velocity; instead, he wins with precision, preparation, and experience. Just as importantly, he knows Detroit. Verlander understands Comerica Park, the city’s expectations, and the demands of a playoff chase.
Pairing him with Skubal would instantly give the Tigers one of the most credible one-two punches in the American League. From both a baseball and branding perspective, a “Justin Verlander Tigers reunion” feels almost inevitable
If the Tigers are looking for intensity, Max Scherzer delivers it in abundance. Few pitchers embody competitive fire like Scherzer, and that edge would be contagious on a young roster. He no longer needs to carry a staff — he needs to set the tone.
Scherzer’s relentless preparation, toughness, and refusal to cut corners would elevate the standards throughout the clubhouse. In a season where margins are razor-thin, that mentality can be the difference between fighting for a wild card and winning the division.
Neither Verlander nor Scherzer would require a long-term commitment, which is exactly why the move makes sense. Detroit can go all-in without sacrificing its future. The payroll is flexible. The AL Central is wide open. Skubal is at his peak.
Failing to act would be a serious misstep.
This Is What Contenders Do
Championship-caliber teams recognize their moment and move decisively. The Tigers already have the ace, the momentum, and the opportunity. What they need now is experience — the kind that only battle-tested veterans can provide.
Adding Justin Verlander or Max Scherzer wouldn’t be about nostalgia. It would be about urgency. About honoring Skubal’s brilliance. And about showing that Detroit isn’t just building toward something — it’s ready to win now.
And heading into 2026, that difference matters more than ever.
Leave a Reply